A new chapter in the iPhone’s app ecosystem is unfolding as “Hot Tub,” the first native pornography app for iOS, is set to launch in the European Union. This development comes via the alternative app store AltStore PAL, enabled by the European Union’s Digital Markets Act (DMA), which mandates Apple to allow third-party app stores on iOS devices.
What is Hot Tub?
Hot Tub is an aggregator app designed to help iOS users search and stream adult content from popular websites like Pornhub, Xvideos, XNXX, and XHamster. Unlike browsing these sites through Safari, Hot Tub offers a more streamlined experience with built-in search, customizable controls, and an ad-free environment. The app even includes premium features like advanced filtering and gesture-based navigation for subscribers.
Understanding the Digital Markets Act (DMA)
The Digital Markets Act (DMA) is a regulatory framework introduced by the European Union to promote fair competition and curb the monopolistic practices of big tech companies. The DMA targets “gatekeepers” like Apple, Google, and Meta, which control essential digital platforms. One of its most impactful mandates is requiring Apple to allow third-party app stores on iOS devices, breaking the company’s long-standing exclusivity over app distribution.
The DMA aims to foster innovation, provide consumers with more choices, and prevent tech giants from abusing their dominant market positions. By opening up the iOS ecosystem, the DMA empowers developers to reach audiences without being subject to Apple’s stringent App Store rules and hefty commission fees.
We previously discussed this in detail, highlighting how Apple’s approach to complying with the DMA has resulted in a two-tier iPhone experience. In our article, we noted that Apple’s decision to limit these changes to EU markets creates a fragmented user experience globally. The Hot Tub app is a prime example of this disparity – if you’re outside the EU, you will likely never see or even know it exists because you don’t have access to alternative app stores like AltStore PAL.
Apple’s Response: A Firm Denial
While the app has passed Apple’s Notarization process — a security and privacy review required for all third-party apps — Apple has firmly denied any direct approval of Hot Tub. Tech journalist Mark Gurman highlighted Apple’s stance in a recent post on X (formerly Twitter), stating:
“Apple says developer assertion that it ‘approved’ Hot Tub — the first porn app on iPhones available in the EU due to external app store rules — is a lie. It says the EU policies undermine safety and consumer trust and it would never approve a porn app in its App Store.”
Apple maintains that while it ensures baseline platform integrity through Notarization, the content guidelines enforced on its official App Store do not apply to external marketplaces like AltStore PAL. This distinction is critical in understanding Apple’s denial, as the company argues that it would never sanction such an app within its own ecosystem.
Apple’s Notarization process is a security measure designed to verify the integrity of apps distributed outside the App Store. When developers submit their apps for Notarization, Apple scans them for malicious code, security vulnerabilities, and privacy issues. Although this process ensures that apps meet basic security standards, it does not involve content moderation or approval, which is why apps like Hot Tub can pass through despite Apple’s content policies.
The Consequences of Alternative App Stores
The introduction of alternative app stores in the EU is a direct consequence of the DMA, designed to foster competition and reduce the monopolistic grip of tech giants like Apple. While this policy promotes innovation and consumer choice, it also opens the door to apps that Apple would traditionally reject, such as Hot Tub.
This raises concerns about user safety, content moderation, and the potential for harmful applications to slip through the cracks. Apple argues that these risks undermine consumer trust, as third-party stores may not uphold the same rigorous standards for app quality and security.
Arguments Against Monopolies
Monopolies stifle innovation, limit consumer choice, and allow companies to impose unfair pricing and policies. In the context of app distribution, Apple’s monopoly over the App Store has been criticized for its high commission fees, restrictive guidelines, and lack of transparency. The DMA seeks to dismantle these barriers, encouraging a more competitive and dynamic digital marketplace.
Lessons from Android’s Open Ecosystem
Android has long supported alternative app stores and sideloading of apps, offering users greater flexibility compared to iOS. Despite this openness, Android maintains robust security features, such as:
- App Permissions: Users can control what data and system features apps can access.
- Play Protect: A security system that scans apps for malware, even those installed from outside the Play Store.
- Installation Warnings: Android issues warnings when users attempt to install apps from unknown sources, ensuring they are aware of potential risks.
These measures demonstrate that it’s possible to maintain a secure environment while allowing alternative app stores. Apple’s concerns about safety, while valid, can be addressed through similar mechanisms.
Navigating the Middle Ground
Despite these challenges, there are ways Apple could mitigate the risks without defying EU regulations. One potential solution is to require developers to clearly tag adult or sensitive content during the Notarization process. Additionally, Apple could introduce an opt-in feature, allowing users to decide whether they want to view or access such apps within third-party stores. This approach would respect user autonomy while maintaining a layer of protection.
Why Openness is Better Than Closed Systems
While closed ecosystems like Apple’s App Store offer a curated, secure environment, they also limit freedom and innovation. Openness fosters diversity, competition, and technological advancement. It empowers users to make their own choices and developers to explore creative solutions without being constrained by restrictive policies.
The EU’s push for open technology ecosystems through the DMA is a step in the right direction. It promotes transparency, reduces the risk of monopolistic abuse, and ultimately benefits both consumers and developers. The Hot Tub case illustrates the complexities of this transition, but it also highlights the potential for a more vibrant and inclusive digital landscape.
Hot Tub’s imminent launch marks a pivotal moment in the iOS ecosystem, signaling both the opportunities and challenges that come with greater app store freedom. Whether this will set a precedent for more controversial apps remains to be seen, but one thing is clear: the way we think about app distribution on iOS has fundamentally changed.
Discover more from Techish Kenya
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
